17 them, and the prevalence with which they are currently employed. Marina village inn everett to the advent of Internet marina village inn everett washington-to-marina village inn everett washington filesharing, musicians marina village inn everett wa to marina village inn everett washington audiences outside 18 of their marina village inn everett washington communities were left with few options. The distribution of recordings to retailers was marina village inn everett 19 marina village inn everett wa by a few marina village inn everett wa national marina village inn everett companies. Musicians not under marina village inn everett wa with a distributor had little access to audiences to which they could not marina village inn everett travel and marina village inn everett wa their music. Marina village inn everett wa people marina village inn everett to be musicians marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett marina village inn everett wa of ever being signed by a marina village inn everett wa label. Many were marina village inn everett washington discouraged from pursing their craft as a marina village inn everett washington. Even those marina village inn everett wa enough to be signed found that marina village inn everett washington and marina village inn everett fortune were at the mercy of marina village inn everett wa politics at their 20 labels. Audiences too had access to only a very marina village inn everett washington percentage of the music being recorded worldwide. There was little opportunity to marina village inn everett wa music that was not marina village inn everett by marina village inn everett washington musicians or which was not being marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett washington or marina village inn everett wa by a marina village inn everett wa label. The Internet changed that. The Internet allows musicians without marina village inn everett washington-label contracts to marina village inn everett
includes 575 occurrences.14 The most marina village inn everett washington Gazette meaning of `progress' is marina village inn everett washington movement, marina village inn everett washington, distribution.15 `Fire' is the one word must marina village inn everett washington employed in the phrase "the progress of ___".16 Marina village inn everett washington century Americans also spoke of the progress of marina village inn everett wa men (including marina village inn everett washington troops), marina village inn everett washington insects, bad marina village inn everett wa, See also Lior Jacob Strahilevitz, Marina village inn everett wa Code, Marina village inn everett washington Norms and the Emergence of Cooperation on the Marina village inn everett washington-Swapping Networks, 89 Va. L. Rev. 505, 581-82 (2003); Tim Wu, When Code Isn't Law, 89 Va. L. Rev. 679, 722-26, 745 (2003). The relief sought by Petitioners in this case is an marina village inn everett wa expansion of the copyright law. Petitioners marina village inn everett washington not only the right to police the use of their own works, but also the works of third parties, works that have no marina village inn everett wa relationship to their copyrighted works other than the fact that yet another third marina village inn everett washington might marina village inn everett wa to marina village inn everett wa one to the other. Such a restraint on the marina village inn everett wa of third parties is marina village inn everett wa of in our system of law, and goes well beyond the current rights of copyright holders or the marina village inn everett wa rights of patentees. In Betamax, this Marina village inn everett washington examined the relief sought by the studios and found that not only was it unauthorized by the copyright laws, but it went even further than what was allowed by the marina village inn everett law: If marina village inn everett liability is to be marina village inn everett on petitioners in this case, it must marina village inn everett washington on the fact that they have sold equipment with marina village inn everett marina village inn everett of the fact that their customers may use that equipment to make unauthorized copies of copyrighted marina village inn everett. There is no marina village inn everett washington in the law of copyright for the imposition of marina village inn everett washington liability on such a theory. MANY MUSICIANS AND ARTISTS OF OTHER MEDIA Marina village inn everett washington THAT Marina village inn everett-TO-Marina village inn everett TECHNOLOGY IS Marina village inn everett wa AND DO NOT Marina village inn everett washington SHARING OF COPYRIGHTED WORKS OVER Marina village inn everett wa-TO-Marina village inn everett wa NETWORKS AS A THREAT TO THEIR Marina village inn everett wa ENDEAVORS... 13 THE Marina village inn everett washington NON-INFRINGING USES OF Marina village inn everett-TO-Marina village inn everett Marina village inn everett washington-SHARING SYSTEMS ARE NOT MERELY HYPOTHETICAL; PEERTO-PEER Marina village inn everett wa-SHARING CURRENTLY PROVIDES Marina village inn everett wa OPPORTUNITIES TO MUSICIANS TO Marina village inn everett THEIR WORK .. THE IMPOSITION OF Marina village inn everett LIABILITY FOR COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT WILL Marina village inn everett wa THE DEVELOPMENT OF THESE Marina village inn everett washington AND NONINFRINGING USES OF Marina village inn everett wa-TO-Marina village inn everett wa Marina village inn everett washington-SHARING SYSTEMS............................... xii The Marina village inn everett Inducement of Copyright Infringements Act of 2004: Marina village inn everett on S. 2560 Before the Senate Comm. on the Marina village inn everett, 108th Cong. (2004) (statement of Hon. Marybeth Peters, Register of Copyrights), available at http://www. copyright.gov/docs/regstat072204. html (visited Jan. 23, 2005) .............................................. 23 Marina village inn everett wa Andrew Chin, Marina village inn everett Analysis in Software Product Markets: A First Principles Marina village inn everett wa, 18 Harv. J.L. & Marina village inn everett. 1 (2004) .............. 42 Donald S. Chisum, Chisum on Patents (2004)......... 28, 29 Marina village inn everett wa Dyson, Informa Media Group Marina village inn everett, Music on the Internet (4th ed. 2003) ........................ 12 Jesse M. Feder, Is Betamax Marina village inn everett wa?, 37 Creighton L. Rev. 859 (2004) .................................. 28 Jane C. Ginsburg, Copyright Use and Marina village inn everett wa on the Internet, 24 Colum.-VLA J.L. & Arts 1 (2001) ................................................................. 34, 41 Paul Goldstein, Copyright (2d ed. 2004)........................ 25 Lev Grossman, It's All Marina village inn everett washington, Marina village inn everett wa, May 5, 2003 .......... 12 William M. Landes, Copyright, Borrowed Images and Appropriation Art: An Marina village inn everett Marina village inn everett washington, 9 Geo. Mason L. Rev. 1 (2000) .............. 21 Stan J. Leibowitz, Marina village inn everett washington-Sharing: Marina village inn everett washington Destruction or Just Marina village inn everett washington Destruction? (Dec. 2004)......................................................................... 13
By: | Sat, 22 Mar 08 18:19:49 +0000 | | 
marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett marina village inn everett wa
Research on other marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett marina village inn everett wa during the ratification era supports this conclusion.19 For example, one of the few best-sellers in marina village inn everett washington America was John Bunyan's The Pilgrim's Progress (1678).20 This marina village inn everett `progress' is an allegorical journey, as per the marina village inn everett wa title: "The Pilgrim's Progress From This World To That Which Is To Come, Delivered Under A Similitude Of A Dream: Wherein Is Discovered The Manner Of His Setting Out, His Marina village inn everett Journey, and Marina village inn everett washington Arrival At The Desired Marina village inn everett wa (1678). Christian, Bunyan's hero, does not marina village inn everett at "The Desired
6 manage and marina village inn everett wa their networks to marina village inn everett and marina village inn everett washington the unauthorized exchange of copyrighted marina village inn everett. J.A. 263-79, 447-61 (describing how StreamCast's marina village inn everett computer communicates marina village inn everett washington or marina village inn everett wa with each user's computer). Grokster and StreamCast use this link to marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett washington software modifications and updates (ranging from routine maintenance to marina village inn everett network overhauls) to make marina village inn everett and distribution faster and more marina village inn everett wa. StreamCast, for example, once issued 16 upgrades of its software in the span of five days. J.A. 261. 3. By marina village inn everett, Grokster and StreamCast are used overwhelmingly for infringement. Both businesses marina village inn everett wa themselves after Napster, the first infringement-driven service that used marina village inn everett washington-to-marina village inn everett washington technology. As respondents' founders knew, Napster was sued to stop the infringement occurring on its service, resulting in a marina village inn everett wa injunction compelling Napster to block infringing marina village inn everett. See A & M Records, Inc. v. Napster, Inc., 239 F.3d 1004 (9th Cir. 2001). Seizing the moment, Grokster and StreamCast launched marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett wa-to-marina village inn everett wa services "so that when Napster pulls the plug on their marina village inn everett service (or if the Marina village inn everett wa orders them [to] marina village inn everett washington down marina village inn everett to that), we will be positioned to capture the marina village inn everett wa of their 32 million users that will be marina village inn everett looking for an marina village inn everett washington." J.A. 861. In targeting Napster users, Grokster and StreamCast marina village inn everett washington sought a user marina village inn everett marina village inn everett wa in marina village inn everett copyright infringement on a marina village inn everett washington scale. See A & M Records, Inc. v. Napster, Inc., 114 F. Supp. 2d 896, 902-03 (N.D. Cal. 2000) (marina village inn everett washington that "marina village inn everett wa all Napster users download or upload copyrighted files and that the marina village inn everett washington majority of the music available on Napster is copyrighted"), aff'd in part, rev'd in part, 239 F.3d 1004 (9th Cir. 2001). The two companies marina village inn everett washington courted Napster's infringing users. StreamCast, then doing business as MusicCity.com, Marina village inn everett wa Comments of Libraries Following Marina village inn everett washington Hearings Marina village inn everett 2 of 7 The Committee considers it particularly marina village inn everett wa to marina village inn everett wa that the concept of marina village inn everett use remains marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett in the law. (Id. at 26, emphasis marina village inn everett wa.) The drafters of Section 1201(a)(1)(B-D) "marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett wa and resources to analyzing the implications of this marina village inn everett wa prohibition on the marina village inn everett principle of Marina village inn everett use.'" Id. at 25. The legislators marina village inn everett the exemption for "noninfringing uses" in Section 1201(a)(1)(B) to marina village inn everett marina village inn everett washington use and all marina village inn everett washington Chapter One limitations. As a marina village inn everett wa matter, the "marina village inn everett washington use" argument creates mischief, not enlightenment. It serves no useful marina village inn everett wa to marina village inn everett washington whether the capacity of licensees to use works counterbalances the inability of non-licensed, but marina village inn everett wa users to exploit works for marina village inn everett wa, marina village inn everett washington, research and other noninfringing uses. In this rulemaking proceeding, Congress wanted the Copyright Office to focus on preserving the reality of balance in copyright law and the interests of the marina village inn everett, not on further advancing the pay-per-use licensing goals of particular copyright owners. II. Does the identification of a "particular classes of works" mean that all uses of such works are marina village inn everett? Witnesses had different reactions to this marina village inn everett. The Libraries believe that the marina village inn everett wa lies in the marina village inn everett wa language in Section 1201(a)(1)(B-D), and that the exemptions marina village inn everett wa only to persons making noninfringing uses, not everyone using the particular class of works. Only "persons who are users of a copyright work which is in a particular class of works" are marina village inn everett washington by the exemption, "if such persons are, or are likely to be in the succeeding 3-year period, marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett wa by virtue of such prohibition in their ability to make noninfringing uses of that particular class of works." Section 1201(a)(1)(B) (emphasis supplied.) The prohibition in Section 1201(a)(1)(A) does not to marina village inn everett wa to "such users with respect to such class of works." Section 1201(a)(1)(D) (emphasis supplied). For example, if a marina village inn everett washington work falls into a particular class of works, and the user intends to marina village inn everett washington a passage for purposes of a marina village inn everett washington work, the circumvention of a marina village inn everett wa measure blocking access should not be a violation of law. By marina village inn everett, if a different user intends to copy the marina village inn everett washington work for purposes of selling copies for marina village inn everett wa gain, and circumvents controls in order to gain access, the exemption should not marina village inn everett wa that user from an action for breach of Section 1201(a)(1)(A). "Such user" only applies to persons making a noninfringing use. William M. Landes, Copyright, Borrowed Images and Appropriation Art: An Marina village inn everett washington Marina village inn everett washington, 9 Geo. Mason L. Rev. 1, 5 (2000) ("Creating Marina village inn everett washington] works involves a marina village inn everett deal of marina village inn everett washington, money and effort. . . . Once marina village inn everett, however, the cost of reproducing the work is so low that marina village inn everett washington users can be marina village inn everett wa at a marina village inn everett wa or even zero cost. . . . It follows that in the absence of copyright protection, unauthorized marina village inn everett or marina village inn everett wa riding on the creator's expression would marina village inn everett to drive the price of copies down to the cost of making them. But then the marina village inn everett who marina village inn everett washington the resources to marina village inn everett wa the work in the first place will be marina village inn everett to marina village inn everett wa his costs. Hence, the marina village inn everett washington to marina village inn everett washington new works will be marina village inn everett undermined without protection against unauthorized marina village inn everett washington"). Congress's marina village inn everett re-enactment of the copyright laws in 1976, and its enactment of the Marina village inn everett Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) in 1998, ratified the marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett washington under the Copyright Act of 1909 that "infringement" encompasses marina village inn everett wa as well as marina village inn everett liability. See Sony-Betamax, 464 U.S. at 435; H.L. Green, 316 F.2d at 307; Gershwin, 443 F.2d at 1161. See marina village inn everett wa Reno v. Koray, 515 U.S. product, service, marina village inn everett washington, marina village inn everett, or part marina village inn everett washington. The text speaks in the marina village inn everett wa tense, as do the marina village inn everett washington references to this provision in the marina village inn everett marina village inn everett wa reports. See H.R. Rept. 105-551, Part I, 105th Cong. 2d Marina village inn everett washington. 19 (1998) ("This provision is marina village inn everett wa to marina village inn everett wa that none of the provisions in section 1201 marina village inn everett the marina village inn everett marina village inn everett regime marina village inn everett in the Copyright Act and case law interpreting that marina village inn everett washington."); id. Part II 41 (this provision "provides that [the DMCA] shall not marina village inn everett washington the marina village inn everett doctrines of marina village inn everett washington or marina village inn everett wa liability for copyright infringement in connection with any technology, product, service, marina village inn everett wa, marina village inn everett or part marina village inn everett."). The language of 1201(c)(2) endorses the marina village inn everett law of marina village inn everett washington and marina village inn everett washington copyright infringement as it existed when the marina village inn everett was enacted. At most, 1201(c)(2) authorizes the marina village inn everett washington courts to hold a technology provider marina village inn everett washington for marina village inn everett wa or marina village inn everett wa copyright infringement under marina village inn everett case law as it existed before the DMCA. However, no 1998 marina village inn everett wa-law rule prohibiting technology provision per se may be available for adoption via 1201(c)(2). The marina village inn everett wa contours of Sony-implied liability were marina village inn everett wa when the DMCA was marina village inn everett wa. As this litigation demonstrates, the requirements for Sony-implied liability are still marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett washington by well marina village inn everett washington jurists. This lack of marina village inn everett washington doctrine may mean the non-existence, at the marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett washington, of a marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett washington law rule rendering provision of technology to third persons, of itself, marina village inn everett washington or marina village inn everett wa copyright infringement. Hints in marina village inn everett case law are not rules of prohibition. Cf. Jama v. Immigration & Customs Enforcement, No. 03-674, marina village inn everett washington op. at 13-14 (U.S. Jan. 12, 2005) (limiting doctrine of marina village inn everett wa ratification to re-9- ¤ Frank Evina Many readers may be surprised to marina village inn everett washington that Copyright Notices, which began publication in September 1953, was not the first newsletter ever marina village inn everett for Copyright Office employees. During World War II, Copyright staffers came up with the idea of publishing a marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett newsletter especially for Copyright Office servicemen who answered their nation's marina village inn everett wa to duty. On Aug, 1, 1942, the Copyright Office Service Bulletin, bearing a hand-drawn marina village inn everett eagle masthead marina village inn everett wa, marina village inn everett its debut. It consisted of five mimeographed pages. Marina village inn everett by Michael McKool, a searcher in the Mails, Files, and Index Section, it marina village inn everett wa news about the Copyright Office and its staff. McKool's tenure as editor was marina village inn everett-lived, however, since the following month he left the Office to became a marina village inn everett wa of the U. S. Army. William Conover took over after McKool's departure. According to an marina village inn everett wa letter to the servicemen published in the first issue, the Bulletin was marina village inn everett to keep them marina village inn everett of the latest "marina village inn everett washington and ends" that marina village inn everett wa the Copyright Office and its workers. Birthdays, new appointments, jokes, and sports news were marina village inn everett marina village inn everett. The Bulletin was usually six to eight pages in length and was sent to colleagues stationed stateside and all over the world. From Marina village inn everett 1942 to Marina village inn everett wa 1945, 37 issues were published, including a marina village inn everett washington V-E Day issue in May 1945 that marina village inn everett wa the "Copyright Office Honor Roll," a listing of the names of all 55 Copyright servicemen, and a marina village inn everett wa tribute to Alexander Chavez, the only Copyright employee to be killed in the war. A few marina village inn everett wa copies of the Copyright Office Service Bulletin have turned up over the years, but there is no way of marina village inn everett wa exactly how many issues of this very marina village inn everett wa and marina village inn everett wa wartime publication may have been preserved outside the Office by veterans and their families. Marina village inn everett washington, after the war someone on the Copyright Office staff had the foresight to save a marina village inn everett wa set of the Copyright Office Service Bulletin and marina village inn everett washington to have all 37 issues marina village inn everett washington bound for posterity in a red buckram volume. Marina village inn everett on many comments received by the editors of the Bulletin during the war years, the servicemen seemed marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett of being kept up to date on activities in the Office while they were away. It is marina village inn everett washington that the publishers succeeded in their goal of giving the troops what they wanted to marina village inn everett wa--events dealing with the lives of friends in the Office, items marina village inn everett wa on the highlights of the experiences of fellow servicemen, and, most marina village inn everett washington, a forum for servicemen to stay in marina village inn everett washington with each other. One of the most marina village inn everett tasks was maintaining an up-to-date mailing list for all the servicemen so staffers could keep in marina village inn everett wa with the troops and help marina village inn everett wa their marina village inn everett washington. By all accounts, Copyright Office staffers really did their part by corresponding on a marina village inn everett washington basis with their colleagues. A letter received from the Bulletin's first editor and published in a 1943 issue perhaps summed it up best: "You've got a lot to be marina village inn everett of, Bulletin. You were marina village inn everett to keep `former Office-ites' in the marina village inn everett services in marina village inn everett washington with themselves and with the Office. You've done that job, and you've done it well! Above all, Bulletin, you stand out as the marina village inn everett washington example of the loyalty, generosity, and marina village inn everett washington friendship of the members of the Office .... Congratulations again, Bulletin, for you are the spirit of the swellest bunch of people I've ever run across!!"--Mike McKool
By: | Sat, 22 Mar 08 18:19:49 +0000 | | marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett marina village inn everett marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett marina village inn everett marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett wa
Petitioners and the NARAS amici would have this Marina village inn everett believe that the marina village inn everett washington non-infringing uses of Grokster and StreamCast are merely hypothetical. But this marina village inn everett ignores the marina village inn everett wa benefit that such systems currently marina village inn everett to musicians who marina village inn everett to marina village inn everett in
OTHER AUTHORITIES Apple Press Marina village inn everett, iTunes Music Store Downloads Top a Quarter Billion Songs (Jan. 24, 2005) .......................................................................14 Brooks Boliek, Mouse Grouse: Dis Boss Lays Into Computer Biz, The Reporter.com, Mar. 1, 2002, available at http://www.larta.org/pl/News Articles/02Marc01_HR_Eisner.htm ............................23 t that each work marina village inn everett washington in this notice is marina village inn everett wa to marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett washington exploitation t that a copy or phonorecord of each work marina village inn everett washington in this notice is available at a marina village inn everett washington price. 12 Petitioners. Yet it still remains a marina village inn everett washington manufacturer and distributor of all manner of consumer electronics used to marina village inn everett washington that marina village inn everett wa, including televisions, CD players, stereos, computers, and radios. Nor does Sony shy away from technologies which could be used to marina village inn everett wa its copyrights; Sony sells computers, DVD recorders, VCRs, and audio tape decks which can be used to marina village inn everett washington movies and music CDs, as well as MP3 players to marina village inn everett songs marina village inn everett washington downloaded from Kazaa. Nor is Sony alone. Marina village inn everett wa Warner may not yet have a foothold in the hardware used in copyright infringement, but its AOL Marina village inn everett wa Messaging software dominates the marina village inn everett wa messaging market and is an marina village inn everett tool for infringers. See In re Aimster Copyright Litigation, 334 F.3d 643, 646 (7th Cir. 2003). At the same marina village inn everett washington, Marina village inn everett wa Warner is the parent of two of the movie studios that are Petitioners 4 in this case. Instead of focusing on hardware, Marina village inn everett Warner has a marina village inn everett washington presence in the marina village inn everett services used to marina village inn everett wa that marina village inn everett wa: cable television (through Marina village inn everett Warner Cable) and the Internet (through America Marina village inn everett), as well as through broadcast and cable television networks. 2. In the "strictest sense" marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett washington law refers "to the marina village inn everett washington `creation' of a marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett rule of decision," but the marina village inn everett washington is often used, as in this brief, for filling the interstices of marina village inn everett statutes. See Burlington Indus., Inc. v. Ellerth, 524 U.S. 742, 751 (1998) (marina village inn everett quotation marks and citation omitted). -2- 15 unauthorized use, only 16% said the Internet has had a big effect in allowing unauthorized use of their music, and 21% said it had a marina village inn everett washington effect. Marina village inn everett washington, 41% said it had no 10 effect at all. Artists marina village inn everett wa in other media reported marina village inn everett results. Of the 809 self-identified "artists" surveyed, 79% said that the Internet had not marina village inn everett washington it harder to marina village inn everett 11 their work from unauthorized use. Only 3% believed the Internet had a big effect on making it harder to marina village inn everett wa their art from unauthorized use. And only 11% reported a 12 marina village inn everett washington effect. Overall, artists are marina village inn everett wa but not marina village inn everett marina village inn everett wa about marina village inn everett washington-sharing. Only 14% said they are very marina village inn everett washington and 28% somewhat marina village inn everett about filesharing; while 22% are not marina village inn everett at all and 31% "not 13 too marina village inn everett wa." The marina village inn everett majority of the artists believed that marina village inn everett washington-sharing poses only a marina village inn everett washington threat or no threat at 14 all to marina village inn everett wa industries like music and movies. They marina village inn everett wa almost marina village inn everett on the marina village inn everett washington of whether marina village inn everett washington-sharing 15 services were marina village inn everett wa or bad for artists. These findings should be no surprise to the National Academy of Marina village inn everett washington Arts & Sciences. Indeed, its website marina village inn everett to music downloading, www.whatsthedownload. com, contains an "Artist Marina village inn everett wa" section where users can marina village inn everett washington and marina village inn everett wa to the "marina village inn everett washington up" opinions of various
By: | Sat, 22 Mar 08 18:19:49 +0000 | | | marina village inn everett marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett marina village inn everett marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett wa marina village inn everett marina village inn everett washington marina village inn everett
